Skip to content
business12 min read

Why Transformation Efforts Fail: 11 Reasons and How to Finally Triumph

In McKinsey's research, just 26% of transformations were very or completely successful. Here are 11 reasons they fail, the evidence behind each, and what to do instead.

Volodymyr KhitsiakSenior Marketing Manager

Published · Updated

Share

Why Transformation Efforts Fail: 11 Reasons and How to Finally Triumph

Transformation is now a survival imperative, yet most efforts still fall short. In McKinsey’s 2015 survey of organizational transformations, just 26% of respondents said the transformation they knew best had been very or completely successful at both improving performance and sustaining the gains. Transformations fail for recurring reasons: people who resist or were never brought along, unclear direction, leaders who do not model the change, legacy systems, weak communication, and plans that underestimate the work. This guide breaks down 11 of them, each with what the research shows, a real-world example, and what to do instead.

Why transformation is no longer optional

Almost every company is already changing how it works. The difference between those that profit from it and those that do not comes down to execution.

  • Everyone is moving, but the value lags. McKinsey reports that while 90% of companies have launched some form of digital transformation, on average they have realized only a third of the revenue benefits they expected (Rewired to outcompete, 2023). Standing still is not an option, and a half-finished transformation leaves most of the value on the table.
  • Method doubles the odds. In McKinsey’s 2015 survey, the average success rate of 26% more than doubled, to 58%, when organizations followed a rigorous approach and pursued all of the recommended actions. Transformations fail for reasons that can be named and managed, which is what the rest of this guide is about.

Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail (11 Reasons)

John Kotter’s 1995 Harvard Business Review article, Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail, drew on more than 100 companies and gave this question its classic answer. The 11 reasons below update it with more recent research, from leadership and culture to technology and execution.

why transformation efforts fail

#ReasonWhat the research showsReal-world example
1Resistance to changeKPMG (2016): 28% of executives say their existing organizational culture is a barrier to executionMicrosoft’s cultural reset under Satya Nadella
2Lack of clear visionGallup (2018): only 22% of employees strongly agree their leaders have a clear direction for the organizationKodak’s missed opportunity in digital photography
3Inadequate leadership commitmentMcKinsey (2015): transformations are 5.3 times more likely to succeed when senior leaders role model the changes they ask forHP’s reversal on spinning off its PC business in 2011
4Obsolete technology and processesKPMG (2016): 30% of executives say legacy technology and systems are a barrier to successNokia’s reluctance during the smartphone revolution
5Ineffective communicationMcKinsey (2017): transformations are 5.8 times more likely to succeed when the CEO communicates a compelling change storyEnron’s internal communication failures
6Organizational cultureBain & Company (2006): over 80% see a high-performance culture as essential, fewer than 10% succeed in building oneGoogle’s culture of innovation and openness
7Employee engagement and supportGallup: highly engaged business units achieve 23% higher profitabilityGE’s digital transformation struggles in the 2010s
8Lack of training and developmentLinkedIn (2020): 51% of L&D professionals planned to launch upskilling programs that yearAT&T’s plan to retrain hundreds of thousands of employees
9Misalignment of strategy and executionFlyvbjerg and Budzier (2011): one in six IT projects had a cost overrun averaging 200%The flawed rollout of Healthcare.gov
10Underestimating the complexity of changeKPMG (2016): underestimating the operating model changes involved is the most common barrier (37%)Sears struggling against e-commerce giants
11Inconsistent follow-throughStrategy& survey (2013): only 8% of leaders are very effective at both strategy and executionXerox’s wavering focus between core business and diversification

The Challenge of Change (Reasons 1-3)

The first three reasons are about people and leadership: employees resist a change that is imposed on them, nobody can see where it is heading, or leaders do not live it themselves.

“Effective change management, therefore, must transcend beyond the mere communication of the ‘what’ and the ‘how’ of change; it must compellingly articulate the ‘why.’”

Tural Mamedov, Chief Executive Officer at unicrew

1. Resistance to Change

Resistance usually lives in the culture, not in the org chart. In KPMG’s Global Transformation Study, 28% of executives said their existing organizational culture was a barrier to execution. Microsoft shows the other side: when Satya Nadella took over in 2014 and moved the company to a cloud-first strategy, he paired the new direction with a deliberate change in culture, built around what he called a growth mindset.

Solution: “Implement a robust change management strategy that includes transparent communication, employee involvement, and leadership that models the desired change. Recognizing and addressing concerns early can reduce resistance,” said Tural.

2. Lack of Clear Vision

A vision only works if people can see it. Gallup found that only 22% of employees strongly agree their leaders have a clear direction for the organization. Kodak had the technology for digital photography and still missed the opportunity, a lasting example of what a vision disconnect costs.

Advice: Give the direction one owner and one short change story, then check that it reaches the front line. If employees cannot repeat where the organization is heading, it has not been communicated, however often it was announced.

3. Inadequate Leadership Commitment

Employees watch what leaders do, not what they announce. McKinsey found that when senior leaders role model the behavior changes they ask employees to make, transformations are 5.3 times more likely to succeed. HP shows the opposite: in August 2011 it said it was exploring a spin-off of its PC business, then reversed course two months later under a new CEO, leaving customers and staff unsure which direction to follow.

Solution: “Cultivate strong leadership commitment by involving leaders in the planning and execution stages. Encourage them to lead by example, showing their dedication to the transformation through their actions and decisions,” said Ihor Prudyvus, Engineering Director at unicrew.

Technological and Process Hurdles (Reasons 4-5)

New technology often arrives with technical challenges and compatibility issues, while familiar legacy processes quietly limit progress. The fix is a deliberate approach to technology integration and process management, so new tools complement rather than disrupt existing operations.

4. Obsolete Technology and Processes

Old systems hold back new strategies. In the same KPMG study, 30% of executives said legacy technology and systems were a barrier to success, and transformations that started with a specific technology rather than a strategic objective were twice as likely to fail. Nokia’s reluctance to embrace new operating systems during the smartphone revolution is the cautionary tale.

Advice: “Regularly audit and update technological tools and processes. Encourage a culture of continuous improvement and innovation, where staying ahead of technological trends is a priority,” adds Ihor.

The KPMG finding sets the order: start from the business objective, then modernize the systems that stand in its way. That is how we approach legacy software modernization: where an incremental approach is feasible, we work module by module, with each phase tied to priorities the client sets, as when we rebuilt a sports federation’s membership and events platform on .NET Core.

5. Ineffective Communication

The story matters as much as the plan. According to McKinsey’s 2017 survey, a transformation is 5.8 times more likely to succeed when the CEO communicates a compelling, high-level change story, and 6.3 times more likely when senior leaders share aligned messages with the rest of the organization. Enron’s collapse, where what leaders told employees diverged sharply from what was happening inside the company, is the extreme case of the opposite.

Solution: Have the CEO tell a compelling, high-level story of why the change matters, and make sure senior leaders repeat aligned messages: the two actions McKinsey found made transformations 5.8 and 6.3 times more likely to succeed. Add regular updates and a channel where employees can raise concerns, so communication runs both ways.

Cultural and Human Factors (Reasons 6-8)

Reasons 6 to 8 sit in the organization itself: its culture, how engaged its people are, and whether they have the skills the new way of working needs.

“Did you know that the culture of an organization can significantly impact its ability to adapt to change? Cultures prioritizing learning, agility, and innovation typically navigate transformation more successfully.”

Oleksandr Trofimov, Chief Technology Officer at unicrew

6. Organizational Culture

Most leaders already know culture matters; few manage to build the one they want. In a Bain & Company survey of 365 companies, more than 80% of leaders said an organization without a high-performance culture is doomed to mediocrity, yet fewer than 10% of companies succeed in building one. Google is the example most often cited on the other side, with its success in transformation widely attributed to a culture of innovation and openness.

Advice: Culture changes through what leaders do and reward. Name the few behaviors the new culture needs, have leaders model them first, and recognize the people who adopt them.

7. Employee Engagement and Support

Engagement shows up on the bottom line. Gallup found that, taken together, the behaviors of highly engaged business units result in 23% higher profitability. GE’s struggles with its digital transformation in the 2010s are a reminder of what is at stake.

Solution: “Increase engagement by involving employees in decision-making processes, providing opportunities for growth, and recognizing their contributions. Engaged employees are more likely to support and contribute to transformation efforts,” adds Oleksandr.

8. Lack of Training and Development

New ways of working need new skills. LinkedIn’s 2020 Workplace Learning Report found that 51% of learning and development professionals planned to launch upskilling programs that year. AT&T shows the scale it can take: Harvard Business Review described its plan, in 2016, to retrain hundreds of thousands of employees for a changing business.

Solution: Identify the skills the transformation needs before it starts, and fund training for them alongside the technology budget, so people can use the new systems from the first day.

Strategic and Tactical Missteps (Reasons 9-11)

The last three reasons are about execution: plans that ignore risk, change that turns out bigger than expected, and strategies nobody follows through on.

“Why do well-intended visions often fall short in execution? This discrepancy usually arises when a realistic plan and sufficient resources do not underpin ambitious goals. How can organizations bridge the gap between visionary thinking and practical execution?”

Ihor Prudyvus, Engineering Director at unicrew

9. Misalignment of Strategy and Execution

In IT projects, the average hides the real danger. Bent Flyvbjerg and Alexander Budzier studied 1,471 IT projects and found an average cost overrun of 27%, but one in six was a “black swan”, with a cost overrun of 200% on average and a schedule overrun of almost 70% (Harvard Business Review, 2011). A strategy that budgets for the average while delivery faces that tail is where strategy and execution come apart. The flawed rollout of Healthcare.gov is a stark example.

Advice: Plan for the tail, not the average. The same researchers recommend a stress test of readiness before any large technology project, and breaking big projects into ones of limited size, complexity and duration. Involve the people responsible for execution when you set the plan, so strategy and delivery rest on the same assumptions.

10. Underestimating the Complexity of Change

Transformation reaches further into the business than most plans assume. In KPMG’s study, the most commonly identified barrier to success, named by 37% of executives, was underestimating the operating model changes needed to carry a transformation across the organization. Sears’ struggle to compete with e-commerce giants is a classic case of underestimating how much had to change.

Solution: Map the operating model changes the transformation requires, including roles, processes, decision rights and systems, before you start, and revisit that map at each stage.

11. Inconsistent Follow-Through

Strategy and execution are rarely strong in the same leader. In a Strategy& survey of nearly 700 executives, only 8% of top leaders were rated very effective at both strategy and execution (Harvard Business Review, 2015). Xerox’s wavering focus between its core business and diversification shows how inconsistent follow-through stalls a strategy.

Solution: “Establish a system of accountability and regular progress reviews. Keep the team focused on long-term goals and ensure consistent efforts in executing the strategy,” said Ihor.

Bonus: 5 Books to Read About Transformations

Five books go deeper on why transformation efforts fail and how to make them successful.

BookAuthorWhat it covers
Leading ChangeJohn P. KotterOutlines eight common reasons why transformation efforts fail and offers a framework for successful change management.
Our Iceberg Is Melting: Changing and Succeeding Under Any ConditionsJohn Kotter and Holger RathgeberA fable about penguins facing a melting iceberg that illustrates the challenges and dynamics of organizational change and offers practical lessons on overcoming obstacles.
Switch: How to Change Things When Change Is HardChip Heath and Dan HeathExplores the psychological and behavioral aspects of change, explaining why people resist transformation and providing strategies for overcoming resistance.
The Innovator’s Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms to FailClayton ChristensenFocuses on disruptive innovation while discussing why established organizations struggle with transformation and how to navigate disruptive change successfully.
The Lean Startup: How Today’s Entrepreneurs Use Continuous Innovation to Create Radically Successful BusinessesEric RiesProvides insights into applying lean principles and experimentation to transformation efforts in larger organizations.

Conclusion

Transformations fail for reasons that can be named: people who were not brought along, leaders who did not model the change, systems that could not carry the new strategy, and plans that ignored the tail risks. The research above shows what moves the odds. Where the obstacle is technology, modernize with the business objective in front: our legacy software modernization work assesses which parts of a system can be retained, whether old and new can run side by side, and how each phase affects your operations.

Need this built, not just read about?

Tell us what you are building. We will map the fastest route from where you are now to a working product.

Book a scoping call

Thank you

Thanks for your message. We will get in touch with you shortly.