The FTC Click-to-Cancel Rule Was Vacated. What SaaS Teams Still Have to Build
The FTC click-to-cancel rule was vacated in 2025, but subscription compliance still matters. Here's what SaaS products must do now under ROSCA and state laws.

The FTC’s click-to-cancel rule would have required subscription services to make cancellation as easy as signup. It was finalized in October 2024 and vacated by the Eighth Circuit in July 2025. The obligations underneath it did not go away: the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act (ROSCA) still requires clear disclosure, express consent and a simple way to stop recurring charges, and state laws such as California’s require subscriptions sold online to be cancellable online. For any SaaS product that bills consumers on a recurring basis, these rules are not optional.
In March 2026 the FTC formally reopened the question with an advance notice of proposed rulemaking. For SaaS owners, the practical question remains the same: can your users cancel as easily as they signed up?
What is the FTC Click-to-Cancel Rule?
The FTC’s click-to-cancel rule was part of its updated Negative Option Rule, finalized in October 2024. It would have given subscription services a clear directive: make cancellation as easy as signup. For anyone running a SaaS platform or digital service with recurring billing, the core principle is straightforward: no hidden cancel buttons, no guilt-trip messaging, no obstacle-course exit flows.
The rule was part of a longer campaign against “dark patterns”: deceptive UX tactics that lock customers in through hidden cancel buttons, repeated confirmation dialogs, or cancellation flows that require a phone call. With civil penalties for ROSCA violations reaching $53,088 per violation, the FTC’s current inflation-adjusted maximum, cancellation design is not a compliance footnote. It is a product requirement with direct financial consequences: in September 2025, Amazon agreed to pay a $1 billion civil penalty and $1.5 billion in refunds to settle FTC allegations that it enrolled consumers in Prime without their consent and knowingly made it difficult to cancel.
The Rule Was Vacated in 2025, and the FTC Reopened Rulemaking in 2026
On July 8, 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC’s click-to-cancel rule on procedural grounds, finding the agency had failed to conduct a required preliminary analysis of the rule’s costs and benefits. The rule is not currently in effect as a federal mandate.
The obligations that remain come through other channels:
- ROSCA: For subscriptions sold online, 15 U.S.C. 8403 requires sellers to disclose all material terms before collecting billing information, obtain the consumer’s express informed consent before charging, and provide simple mechanisms to stop recurring charges.
- Section 5 of the FTC Act: The FTC continues to bring cases against unfair or deceptive subscription practices under its existing authority, as the Amazon Prime settlement shows.
- State auto-renewal laws: California’s law, as amended by AB 2863 for contracts from July 1, 2025, requires a business that sells a subscription online to let consumers cancel online, at will, through a prominent link or button in their account or settings (or a ready-made cancellation email), and to offer cancellation in the same medium the consumer used to sign up. Other states, including New York, have their own auto-renewal laws.
- Payment network rules: Since April 2020, Visa’s rules for subscription merchants that offer free trials or introductory offers have required an easy way to cancel online, regardless of how the cardholder signed up, and a reminder with a cancellation link at least seven days before a recurring charge begins.
On January 30, 2026, the FTC sent a draft advance notice of proposed rulemaking on negative option plans to the Office of Management and Budget, and it published the notice on March 13, 2026. It asks whether the Negative Option Rule needs amendments to help consumers avoid recurring payments they did not intend and cancel without unwarranted obstacles. The comment period closed on April 13, 2026, and as of November 2026 no proposed rule has followed. The direction of travel is clear: easy cancellation is becoming the expected standard regardless of which specific rule is in force.
Common Violations to Avoid
The FTC’s intent is the same in the vacated rule and in its current enforcement: subscriptions should be simple to leave. Companies typically go wrong in four ways:
- Hiding the Cancel Option: Burying the cancel button under layers of settings or obscure pages is a red flag under any regulatory framework.
- Adding Friction Through Extra Steps: Requiring users to repeatedly confirm their identity or submit lengthy feedback before a cancellation is processed adds the kind of friction regulators look for.
- Making People Call to Cancel: Requiring a phone call to cancel a subscription sold online breaks California’s rule that online sign-ups can be cancelled online, and it is the kind of obstacle ROSCA’s “simple mechanisms” requirement targets.
- Using Dark Patterns to Discourage Cancellation: Guilt-trip messaging (“We’ll be lost without you!”) or repeated “Are you sure?” confirmations designed to wear users down fall into deceptive practice territory under Section 5 of the FTC Act.

What to Build into Your Sign-Up and Cancellation Flows
Each legal duty above maps to a product change. Steps 1 and 2 cover what ROSCA and California’s law require. Steps 3 and 4 are optional retention practices that stay inside those limits.
1. Disclose the Terms and Capture Consent at Sign-Up
Before you collect billing details, show the material terms clearly: the price, how often you charge, that the plan renews automatically, and how to cancel. ROSCA requires that disclosure before billing information is collected. Then capture consent with an action the user takes, such as ticking an unchecked box, rather than a pre-checked one, and send an acknowledgment that repeats the terms and explains how to cancel; California requires both. Before a price or material change, tell users in advance, and for annual plans California also requires a yearly reminder.
2. Make Cancellation as Direct as Sign-Up
Put a clear “Cancel subscription” link or button in the account dashboard or settings and keep it visible. For subscriptions sold online, California requires a prominently located link or button (or a ready-made cancellation email) that lets the user cancel online, at will, without further steps that obstruct or delay it. Use plain wording, keep the steps to a minimum, and give mobile users the same flow as desktop users. Process the cancellation promptly, or at the end of the billing period you disclosed at sign-up.
3. Keep Any Save Step Short and Skippable
If you want to show users what they will lose, or make them an offer, do it in a single step that sits beside the cancel option. California allows a discount, a retention benefit or information about the effects of cancellation only if a prominent “click to cancel” link or button is displayed with it the whole time, and the cancellation is processed promptly when the user clicks it. A brief, relevant reminder of your product’s value fits within that; repeated screens and aggressive sales pressure do not.
4. Make Any Offer About Real Value
If you make an offer in that step, make it about genuine value rather than just price. Consider an extended trial of a premium feature the user has not yet tried, or access to educational content that helps them get more out of the product. Use their usage data to make the offer relevant. A personalized offer at the right moment signals that you understand their needs, not just their billing cycle.
Why Compliance Strengthens Your SaaS Brand
Retention is worth protecting: Bain & Company found that in financial services, a 5% increase in customer retention produces more than a 25% increase in profit. Building a reputation for fair, transparent subscription practices does not just satisfy regulators; it reinforces the trust and credibility that are the most durable competitive advantages in any SaaS market.
The FTC’s click-to-cancel rule is no longer in force, but it has already shifted user expectations. Consumers now notice when cancellation is difficult, and they talk about it. A product that handles the exit gracefully signals confidence in its own value. That is a stronger retention strategy than any dark pattern ever produced. By combining transparent practices, user-friendly design, and genuine added value, SaaS companies can turn a compliance requirement into a real brand asset.
Sources
- WilmerHale: “Eighth Circuit Vacates the FTC’s Click to Cancel Rule”, wilmerhale.com
- Sidley Austin: “U.S. FTC Click-to-Cancel Rule Struck Down”, sidley.com
- Crowell & Moring: “FTC Moves to Revive Click-to-Cancel Rule Following Eighth Circuit Vacatur”, crowell.com
- Latham & Watkins: “FTC Delays Enforcement of Click-to-Cancel Rule”, lw.com
- Greenberg Traurig: “FTC Announces Final Click-to-Cancel Rule”, gtlaw.com
- Federal Register: “Rule Concerning the Use of Prenotification Negative Option Plans” (advance notice of proposed rulemaking, March 13, 2026), federalregister.gov
- eCFR: 16 CFR 1.98, “Adjustment of civil monetary penalty amounts”, ecfr.gov, and the FTC’s notice keeping the 2025 amounts for 2026, federalregister.gov (September 15, 2026)
- 15 U.S.C. 8403 (ROSCA), law.cornell.edu
- California Business and Professions Code 17602, as amended by AB 2863, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov
- FTC: “FTC Secures Historic $2.5 Billion Settlement Against Amazon” (September 25, 2025), ftc.gov
- Visa: “Updated Policy for Subscription Merchants Offering Free Trials or Introductory Promotions”, visa.com
Need to change your sign-up or cancellation flow? Our SaaS development teams work inside your codebase, reviews and release process, so the change ships the way your product already ships. Our UI/UX design team creates the flows, prototypes and production screens with the engineering context needed to build them. Talk to our team about your subscription flow.
Frequently asked questions
No. As of November 2026, the FTC’s click-to-cancel rule is not in effect as a federal mandate: the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated it in July 2025 on procedural grounds. In March 2026 the FTC published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking asking whether, and how, to amend the Negative Option Rule; no proposed rule has followed yet.
ROSCA, Section 5 of the FTC Act, and state auto-renewal laws still apply. ROSCA requires clear disclosure, express consent and a simple way to stop recurring charges, and California requires subscriptions sold online to be cancellable online.
Partly. The vacated FTC rule covered B2B subscriptions, but ROSCA and most state auto-renewal laws are written to protect consumers, so B2B coverage is less settled. Consumer-grade cancellation is the safe default for any recurring billing relationship, whether the customer is a consumer or a business.
Civil penalties for ROSCA violations can reach $53,088 per violation, the FTC's inflation-adjusted maximum for 2025, which it kept unchanged for 2026. State auto-renewal laws carry their own penalty structures, and violations can trigger class action liability as well. Beyond financial penalties, the reputational damage from enforcement actions or negative coverage of dark-pattern cancellation flows can exceed the fines themselves.
One that lets the customer cancel the way they signed up, without obstacles. In practice, that means plain language (“Cancel subscription,” not “Pause your journey”), no required phone call or live chat for an online sign-up, and cancellation processed immediately or at the end of the billing period disclosed at signup. ROSCA adds the federal baseline: a simple way to stop recurring charges.
Under California’s auto-renewal law, a subscription sold online must be cancellable online, at will, through a prominently located link or button in the account or settings (or a ready-made cancellation email), and cancellation must be available in the same medium the customer used to sign up. A retention offer is allowed only if a “click to cancel” option stays visible beside it and the cancellation is processed promptly when the customer uses it.


